Psychology Today vs. First Session

Which is right for you? We break down the pros, cons, and which option is best for lasting, impactful change.

Platform Overviews

Psychology Today offers a directory of therapists and mental health professionals. You can filter therapist profiles by location, specialization, and other criteria to find a therapist who meets your needs. Each listing offers a basic bio and details about each therapist, which is written by the therapist and often involves long-winded academic therapy language.

Once you’ve selected a provider, you can reach out directly to the schedule an appointment using a web form.

Sessions take place in person, over the phone, or through video calls, depending on your therapist's preferences and availability. 

Unlike with First Session, you can’t book therapy sessions directly through the platform. The responsibility to arrange sessions with therapists is entirely on you, which can make the experience less streamlined. Some therapists may have a full practice without indicating, and some may not respond at all to inquiries.

You can connect with Psychology Today therapists from Canada. Insurance coverage is often dependant on the designation of the practitioner.

Therapists have the option of adding a 15 second video which is often a selfie style video, and therapists can typically list as many specializations or focus areas as they'd like.

First Session makes your search for a therapist user-friendly, transparent, and trustworthy. Their mission is to make mental healthcare more approachable and transparent, empowering you to take control of your health.

As the only Canadian therapy platform that prioritizes client-therapist fit, First Session puts you in control of your experience, letting you filter therapists by specialization, location, and designation. In-depth introductory videos help you assess for fit and make an informed decision on whether a therapist’s approach is right for you.

First Session offers transparent pricing, as well as lists real time availability of all therapists on their platform. All therapists' designations are listed and vetted so you can assess insurance coverage requirements before you book, and you can also message each therapist for questions. You can instantly book a free consultation or a full session with any therapist, online or in-person, on the First Session platform.

Feature Comparison

Psychology Today First Session
Direct booking from platform
Curated network of licensed therapists
Free initial consultation
Diverse range of therapeutic approaches
Real time availability of therapists
Through interview based vetting process
Transparent pricing information
In-depth therapist videos tp assess fit

Psychology Today vs First Session Summary

Psychology Today offers a huge roster of therapists, but that’s about the extent of benefits. The contact and booking process is a time-consuming, manual process. Additionally, therapist bios are somewhat generic and repetitive, making it difficult to truly assess for fit. In contrast, First Session allows you to book directly from their platform, and features a vetted and curated list of therapists with in-depth videos to assess for fit.

Why you should consider First Session

First Session fixes the exhausting process of finding the right client-Therapist fit.

The Drawbacks of Psychology Today

Many therapists not accepting new clients or not diligent in responding to inquiries.
Emotional stress from constantly messaging therapists and being disappointed during initial meeting due to lack of information.
Overwhelming selection with generic sounding bios not revealing relevant information to assess therapist-fit.

The First Session Experience

Confidence you have all the information to book a therapist that understands you, directly and easily through the platform.
Assess for fit before booking and find the right (available) therapist the first time.
Relief in knowing each therapist was thoroughly vetted to be listed on the First Session platform.

Meet Your Therapist

With First Session, you're the one in control of your therapy experience.
“I wish I’d known about this platform sooner! I loved the introductory videos–this is what helped me choose the therapist to book an intro consultation with.”
— Satisfied First Session User
“I was able to use First Session to find my therapist for the past two years within 24 hours. First Session eliminated a lot of the friction associated with finding a therapist....”
— Satisfied First Session User
“Having short videos of the therapists sharing a little bit about themselves and their approaches is such a simple concept but made an  absolute world of difference.”
— Satisfied First Session User

Impactful Therapy Begins with the Right Fit

Finding the right therapist shouldn’t feel like an endless search. With platforms like Psychology Today, you may end up overwhelmed by too many choices or left to handle everything on your own, from searching therapists to booking appointments. 

This can lead to emotional stress as you repeatedly switch providers and have to re-explain your feelings to therapists who may not be the right fit. That’s why 50% of people seeking care don’t get past an initial consultation.

At First Session, we believe client-therapist fit is the most important factor of long-term therapy success. We give you all the information you need to make an informed choice, allowing you to connect directly with the therapist you choose, all within our streamlined platform.

Ready to talk? Browse our list of rigorously-vetted therapists and book directly from the First Session platform.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the advantages and disadvantages of in-person vs online therapy?

The answering to that question is "it depends." Research shows that one of the defining features of productive therapy is consistent work with a single Therapist over the long-term. With that in mind, both in-person and online therapy can be equally as effective. However, it depends entirely on the online therapy platform chosen and the quality of the client-therapist relationship.

For example, BetterHelp does not emphasize the importance of client-therapist fit, and instead focuses on instantly matching therapy seekers with a Therapist. It's a trial and error process that is time-consuming and less likely to produce impactful results.

Other platforms like First Session place big emphasis on client-therapist fit, with the goal of matching therapy seekers to a single Therapist for the long-term.

In cases like First Session, the quality and impact of online therapy can match that of an in-person client-therapist relationship. And, of course, some individuals prefer in-person therapy — it's entirely subjective.

To summarize, both can be equally as effective as long as you pay close attention to the quality and approach to therapy of an online platform.

Is online therapy covered by insurance in Canada?

In most cases, yes! However, it's important to note that every employee insurance policy is different. It's increasingly common (if not the norm) for employee insurance programs to cover online therapy. 

As a Step 1, we highly recommend consulting your specific policy or checking in with an HR representative to confirm coverage before booking for any online therapy platform.

For Step 2, you need to check if the online platform of your choice is eligible for insurance coverage or reimbursement. BetterHelp, for example, is not compatible with any insurance plan, so is not eligible for any form of reimbursement or coverage.

On the other hand, First Session is eligible for coverage with the majority of Canadian insurance policy providers and even provides direct billing in many cases.

Step 3, check your coverage for the required Therapist designation or license to ensue coverage (ex. Registered Social Worker, Registered Clinical Counsellor).

First Session makes this process easy by providing explicit details in each Therapist profile page. Check in Insurance Coverage, to see what designations/coverage they fall under.

If you're unsure about coverage, you should ask your benefits provider whether they cover that specific designation of therapist or counsellor. You can also read this guide for more info.

How do I find the right therapist? 

At First Session, we believe finding the right fit in a Therapist is the most important factor to feeling better and having a successful outcome from therapy.

Numerous research studies have proven that forming a strong client-Therapist relationship is more important than the type of therapy used.

To help you assess fit, every Therapist listed on First Session has a short introductory video you can watch to get a sense for who they are.

We've also put together a thorough guide to help you find the right Therapist, determine what the different designations mean, and what you should be looking for when assessing fit. Find the guide here.

Can I find a Therapist according to my age, cultural background, sexuality or gender identity?

Absolutely. We understand that one’s cultural background, age, sexuality, or gender identity can bring unique elements to the process of therapy.

To support every therapy seeker, we actively work to build a highly diverse and inclusive roster of therapists.

For questions or feedback on how we can improve these element of the process, send us a message.

What types of therapists does First Session offer?

First Session therapists support individuals, couples, and families.

Every First Session therapist is accredited and insured to provide online and/or in-person therapy.

Designations of First Session therapists and counsellors include:

  • Psychotherapists
  • Psychotherapists (qualifying)
  • Social Workers
  • Clinical Counsellors
  • Psychologists
  • Canadian Certified Counsellors
  • Provisional Psychologists

You deserve more from therapy.

You've made the courageous decision to reach your full potential. Find the right therapist to help get you there, and make the most of the time and money you’re investing in yourself.